Court Order Confines Man with Tuberculosis to Hospital
Court Order Confines Man with Tuberculosis to Hospital Save Email Print
Posted: 6:09 PM Dec 1, 2008
Last Updated: 6:09 PM Dec 1, 2008
Reporter: Kelly Schlicht
Email Address: kelly.schlicht@weau.com

A | A | A

A man has been ordered confined to an Eau Claire hospital to protect public health. Karl Pha will be forced to accept treatment at Luther-Midelfort for tuberculosis after refusing to take his medicine consistently during at home treatment.

The Eau Claire City County Health Department says Pha needs to be confined to protect the health of his five young children, including an eight-month-old, and also to save his life.

"It's really based on whether a person is infectious and whether they're voluntarily accepting care and a cure for the disease," explains Health Department Director Richard Thoune.

That's the case of 65-year-old Karl Pha, who was diagnosed with tuberculosis in August.

Public Health Nurse Jackie Krumenauer told the court he stopped taking the anti-TB drugs because they caused bad side effects, like extreme itching. Despite education and other interventions, she says he refused treatment.

"He has indicated several times that he thinks he doesn't have TB," testified Krumenauer.

So the health department had to take the very rarely-used last resort—Confinement at Luther-Midelfort.

"Once the patient is suspected of having an airborne disease like tuberculosis, they are put into a separate, special airborne isolation room,” describes Infection Prevention Specialist Sue Shea.

Health care personnel and visitors will have to protect themselves with masks to filter out particles and stop the spread of disease.

"We don't want them transmitting the disease to other persons, so isolation is what is traditionally done."

The health department says TB is spread through coughing, but it's not as contagious as a common cold.

"That's an unfounded fear. It really does require a lot of close contact over a reasonable period of time,” says Thoune. “We're not talking about casual contact with someone in a public setting through a grocery store or anything like that."

But if it's left untreated, TB can still be fatal.

"Would monitoring by hospital staff improve his chances with the tuberculosis?" Judge Proctor asked Pha’s physician, Dr. Noyce, via telephone conference.

"Absolutely," responded Dr. Noyce.

Monday marked the fifth day of Pha's treatment in the hospital. Appearing in court via phone conference, he says his side effects have lessened in the hospital.

The health department says his children have been tested and they're fine. Nurses had recommended giving preventative drugs to the 8 month old baby, but the family stopped after the baby had side effects.

More Stories
WEAU 13 News Director John Hoffland passes away

Share Your Memories of "Hoffland"

Offensive fireworks yanked from shelves

Picnics and Protests Highlight Area Fourth of July Festivities

How to respectfully dispose of an American flag

Wisconsin wardens on the lookout to avoid spread of VHS

Couple weds on parade float

5 motorcycles crash

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Kate Location: Eau Claire on Dec 2, 2008 at 11:57 AM
I didn't say he was confined FOR itching. I said he was confined WITH itching. ;) Relax. I do agree someone with TB ought to obtain treatment and it's good that he is.

Posted by: Emily Location: Eau Claire on Dec 2, 2008 at 09:42 AM
Kate--Did you even READ the article? The itching isn't what he's confined for, he's confined because he has a highly communicable disease that he's refusing to treat. Itching would be a small price to pay, and temporary, to ensure that you wouldn't infect anyone else, wouldn't you agree?

Posted by: Kate Location: Eau Claire on Dec 1, 2008 at 11:07 PM
Confined to Luther Hospital with extreme itching... as someone who has experienced that I sympathize with this man.

Posted by: concerned on Dec 1, 2008 at 08:36 PM
Doesn't this violate the HIPPA regulations by releasing his name to the public?