School Bus Seat Belts
School Bus Seat Belts Save Email Print
Posted: 6:38 PM Feb 20, 2008
Last Updated: 10:42 PM Feb 20, 2008
Reporter: Meghan Kulig
Email Address: meghan.kulig@weau.com

A | A | A

Despite Tuesday’s fatal school bus crash in Minnesota, safety experts say the big yellow buses are still the safest way for kids to get to and from school.

A Lieutenant with the Minnesota State Patrol says there’s no way to know if seat belts would have made a difference in the crash. Still, one expert we spoke with couldn’t think of a single benefit of adding safety belts to his buses.

Jim Fey, with Students Transit Eau Claire, Inc., says about 15,000 students ride his buses each school day.

And Fey says the big buses are designed with your child’s safety in mind.

"They have higher backed seats that are padded and they also give a little bit, so in the course of an impact, those seats absorb, along with the vehicle itself, will absorb some of the impact,” Fey said.

In fact, Fey says seat belts on buses could actually cause more harm than good. For one, he says they could make it difficult to get kids out of the bus in an emergency. Then there’s this concern…

"Maybe it would be used as a weapon,” Fey said. “Where they could take that seat belt and whap someone else with the buckle itself."

Even troopers with the Minnesota State Patrol agree that big yellow buses are the way to go.

"School buses are still a safe means of travel for your children to go to school,” Lt. Mark Peterson said. “And we would still recommend. I think school systems and bus drivers take great pride in their work and what they do."

"It's a tragedy of course that the 4 students were lost in that accident, but in the whole realm of the millions of students that ride a bus everyday to and from school, it is still the safest form of land transportation known to man,” Fey said.

Federal figures show an average of six children are killed on U.S. school buses each year.

More Stories
Wisconsin wardens on the lookout to avoid spread of VHS

Offensive fireworks yanked from shelves

Couple weds on parade float

How to respectfully dispose of an American flag

Picnics and Protests Highlight Area Fourth of July Festivities

Share Your Memories of "Hoffland"

WEAU 13 News Director John Hoffland passes away

Sarah Palin announces resignation as governor

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Mi. on Mar 13, 2008 at 09:49 AM
What you are not understanding is the time a bus takes to burn. It takes less than 2 minutes to be gone. I as a driver of a school bus will not personally drive a bus or allow my children on a bus that has seatbelts.I know I could not get all of my children off of the bus safely if they were in a buckle in the case of a fire. And if I were injered and could'nt help them then what? I love the children I drive everyday and I could not live with myself if I put them in that sort of danger. The other issue for me is in the case of a roll over they could be stuck hanging upside down and not be able to get out to exit in a timily manner out of the hatches. I believe we could save lives with seatbelts in some situations but also in other situations we will loose lives.

Posted by: surf girl Location: CA on Mar 11, 2008 at 11:41 AM
people should be aware that it is safer to wear seatbelts on a school bus no matter what the price is. Kids need to be safe even if it costs us some money!

Posted by: Allie Location: Maplewood on Mar 4, 2008 at 08:14 AM
Hi! My name is Allie! I want to make a difference. I am going to start a fundraiser and donate the money to the bus company. I hope they will buy seatbelts. I am 11 years old. It will be difficult, but I am still going for it! A few days before the crash i said to my mom i might do it. Now that the crash has happened, I said I would go for it! Thank you! -Allie M.

Posted by: Monica Location: Wisconsin on Feb 23, 2008 at 01:32 PM
It sickens me what this guy says, obviously the "padded" high seats did not cushin the childrens heads when they slammed into them because the bus TIPPED over. If they were restrained they all would have still been in there seats. Including the numerous children who were injured. VERY SAD!!!

Posted by: Ngoc Location: OC California on Feb 23, 2008 at 09:52 AM
I couldn't believe this Fey guy commented about the seat belts. The first thought came to my mind when I read the story that these kids could have been saved had there been seat beals installed on the bus.

Posted by: Jeff Location: Illinois on Feb 22, 2008 at 11:07 AM
Can you believe this guy Fey? Seat belts can be dangerous because firefighters would have to cut people out, and they could be weapons. Come on, seat belts in cars have saved thousands of lives. But if we believe this guy, we should be cutting those belts out. And anti-lock brakes are dangerous because they could be used wrong. And airbags are dangerous. Maybe we should take brakes out of cars because people might slam on them and skid. Or perhaps remove headlights because they might blind oncoming motorists.

WEAU 13 News poll
Have a Happy 4th of July Weekend!