Woman accused of killing and dismembering man will get another day in court

The judge will hear from two experts, including one hired by the defense, on whether Taylor Schabusiness is competent to stand trial
Taylor Schabusiness appeared in Brown County court in person for her second competency hearing
Taylor Schabusiness appeared in Brown County court in person for her second competency hearing
Published: May. 10, 2022 at 8:29 AM CDT|Updated: May. 10, 2022 at 3:20 PM CDT
Email This Link
Share on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

GREEN BAY, Wis. (WBAY) - The 24-year-old woman charged with killing and dismembering a Green Bay man appeared in the courtroom in person as a judge heard arguments about whether she’s competent to face trial.

Taylor Schabusiness is charged with 1st Degree Intentional Homicide, Mutilating a Corpse, and 3rd Degree Sexual Assault in one of Green Bay’s most gruesome murders. She appeared at previous court hearings via video conference. Schabusiness appeared fidgety during the brief court hearing, tapping her foot incessantly.

Schabusiness is accused of killing 25-year-old Shad Thyrion and then dismembering his body. Thyrion’s head was located in a bucket and other body parts were found in Schabusiness’s vehicle, prosecutors say.

The defense’s psychologist recommended further evaluation before determining if Schabusiness is competent. A previous psychiatric examination determined Schabusiness was competent. The judge agreed to hold an evidentiary hearing in 9 days to hear testimony from both experts.

If Schabusiness is found not competent, the court will likely order her to undergo treatment until she regains competency.

This was the second competency hearing for Schabusiness. In April, a judge reviewed a psychiatric examination and determined Schabusiness was mentally competent to stand trial and assist in her own defense. Schabusiness’s attorney said he was surprised to hear those results and asked for a second evaluation.

Article continues below the video

Sarah Thomsen describes what she saw as murder suspect Taylor Schabusiness appeared for the hearing in person.

“Ms. Schabusiness has been receiving mental health treatment since the seventh grade. She’s been psychiatrically hospitalized multiple times. She’s been diagnosed with bipolar and psychotic. This may have been one of her better days, however I’m very surprised at the result of this report,” said attorney Quinn Jolly.

Judge Thomas Walsh told the court he would allow a second evaluation to be conducted but questioned doing it at taxpayers’ expense, adding the examiner who found Schabusiness competent has been used in other court cases and found to have been reliable and trustworthy with her exams.

Jolly agreed to ask for funding for an independent evaluation through the State Public Defender’s office. The psychologist’s report was presented to the court last Friday, May 6.

After Schabusiness was arrested in February, she told police she and Thyrion had been doing drugs. After they arrived at the home, they had sex and incorporated chains. Schabusiness said she blacked out during part of it but just went “crazy” and started strangling Thyrion.

Schabusiness told investigators she did not mean to kill Thyrion but she enjoyed choking him and continued to do it. Prosecutors say the sexual assault charge is for acts that happened after the victim died.

Schabusiness is being held on a $2 million cash bond.

A judge ordered an evidentiary hearing after the defense's psychologist said more evaluation is needed

Copyright 2022 WBAY. All rights reserved.